arizona.com Realty.com
  • Buying
  • Selling
  1. Home
  2. NY
  3. Penn Yan
  4. Horning Auctions Company Llc

Horning Auctions Company Llc

874 Rt. 14a

Penn Yan, NY

Team Members

Jeremiah Horning

Ivan Horning

Disclaimer: This page displays real estate agents and offices generated from active and closed MLS listings affiliated with this office. While we make every effort to provide accurate information, there may be inaccuracies due to factors such as fluctuating staff, office name changes, changes of address, and other varying circumstances. If you are the owner of the office or an agent listed here and would like to advertise, please fill out the form at https://www.realty.com/advertise.

Listings & Recent Sales (77)

Active Rental Sold

For Sale (4)

Address Bed / Bath Listing Price
Picture of 4651 W West Sherman Hollow Road
4651 W West Sherman Hollow Road Jerusalem, NY
Living Area: 2984 Sqft.
5 Beds, 2 Baths
$476,300
Picture of 00 Gravel Run Road
00 Gravel Run Road Barrington, NY
-, 0 Baths
$232,000
Picture of 2359 Guyanoga Road
2359 Guyanoga Road Jerusalem, NY
Living Area: 2736 Sqft.
3 Beds, 3 Baths
$550,000
Picture of 147 E Elm Street
147 E Elm Street Milo, NY
Living Area: 2520 Sqft.
5 Beds, 1 Bath
$45,000

Sold (73)

Address Sold date Last List Price Represented
Picture of 2422 Gorham Road
2422 Gorham Road Seneca, NY
Living Area: 1372 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $148,200 Selling
Picture of 1990 Bellona Station Road
1990 Bellona Station Road Benton, NY
Living Area: 1536 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $149,000 Selling
Picture of 4971 Hallock Road
4971 Hallock Road Tyrone, NY
Living Area: 1539 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $156,000 Listing
Picture of 718 Bagley Road
718 Bagley Road Middlesex, NY
Living Area: 2208 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $118,500 Selling
Picture of 466 Voak Road
466 Voak Road Potter, NY
Living Area: 1584 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $225,000 Selling
Picture of 3319 State Route 14a
3319 State Route 14a Milo, NY
Living Area: 4989 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $240,000 Selling
Picture of 2606 E Sherman Hollow Road
2606 E Sherman Hollow Road Jerusalem, NY
Living Area: 2170 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $290,000 Selling
Picture of 3532 Depew Road
3532 Depew Road Gorham, NY
Living Area: 1436 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $425,100 Selling
Picture of 35 N Flat Street
35 N Flat Street Benton, NY
Living Area: 2685 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $147,400 Selling
Picture of 3018 State Route 364
3018 State Route 364 Benton, NY
Living Area: 955 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $190,000 Selling
Picture of 3142 Corwin Road
3142 Corwin Road Jerusalem, NY
Living Area: 1216 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $350,000 Listing
Picture of 449 Pucker Street
449 Pucker Street Tyre, NY
Living Area: 1900 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $153,500 Selling
Picture of 455 Pucker Street
455 Pucker Street Tyre, NY
Living Area: 3164 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $350,000 Selling
Picture of 1072 State Route 14
1072 State Route 14 Torrey, NY
Living Area: 1662 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $316,000 Selling
Picture of 4251 Pulver Road
4251 Pulver Road Tyrone, NY
Living Area: 2312 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $200,000 Selling
Picture of 1404 Kashong Switch Road
1404 Kashong Switch Road Seneca, NY
Living Area: 4324 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $275,000 Selling
Picture of 2074 2nd Milo Road
2074 2nd Milo Road Milo, NY
Living Area: 1899 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $300,000 Selling
Picture of 1310 Phelps Road
1310 Phelps Road Potter, NY
Living Area: 1104 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $182,900 Selling
Picture of 320 Fish Hill Road
320 Fish Hill Road Orange, NY
Living Area: 1588 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $225,000 Selling
Picture of 2417 Havens Corners Road
2417 Havens Corners Road Benton, NY
Living Area: 2506 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $240,000 Selling
Picture of 3840 Arcadia Zurich Norris Road
3840 Arcadia Zurich Norris Road Arcadia, NY
Living Area: 1516 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $119,000 Selling
Picture of 2830 State Route 96A
2830 State Route 96A Lodi, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $75,000 Selling
Picture of 2830 Route 96a Highway
2830 Route 96a Highway Lodi, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $375,000 Selling
Picture of 00 Johnson Road
00 Johnson Road Seneca, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $206,300 Selling
Picture of 00 Co Road 6
00 Co Road 6 Geneva Town, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $682,800 Listing
Picture of 3783 State Route 5 And 20
3783 State Route 5 And 20 Hopewell, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $105,000 Selling
Picture of 5132 Loomis Road
5132 Loomis Road Middlesex, NY
Living Area: 1777 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $345,000 Selling
Picture of 1911 Ellis Road
1911 Ellis Road Barrington, NY
Living Area: 2620 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $376,600 Selling
Picture of 604 W Swamp Road
604 W Swamp Road Potter, NY
Living Area: 2850 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $185,400 Selling
Picture of 932 Hatch Road
932 Hatch Road Junius, NY
Living Area: 3872 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $325,000 Selling
Picture of 264 State Route 414
264 State Route 414 Junius, NY
Living Area: 1849 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $250,000 Selling
Picture of 2209 Sutton Road
2209 Sutton Road Jerusalem, NY
Living Area: 1926 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $359,000 Selling
Picture of 4043 Flint Road
4043 Flint Road Seneca, NY
Living Area: 1716 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $111,000 Selling
Picture of 2241 Havens corners Rd
2241 Havens corners Rd Benton, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,255,000 Selling
Picture of 3830 County House rd
3830 County House rd Jerusalem, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $153,000 Listing
Picture of 2324 Ridge Road
2324 Ridge Road Milo, NY
Living Area: 2436 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,270,000 Selling
Picture of 4107 Italy Hill Road
4107 Italy Hill Road Jerusalem, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $535,000 Listing
Picture of 2150 Vogt Road
2150 Vogt Road Seneca, NY
Living Area: 3552 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $305,000 Selling
Picture of 1851 Yatesville Road
1851 Yatesville Road Potter, NY
Living Area: 1760 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $290,000 Listing
Picture of 2362 Brown Street Extension
2362 Brown Street Extension Milo, NY
Living Area: 1446 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $110,000 Selling
Picture of 5114 Dunton Road
5114 Dunton Road Middlesex, NY
Living Area: 1500 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $255,000 Selling
Picture of 821 S Glenora Road
821 S Glenora Road Starkey, NY
Living Area: 2715 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $420,000 Selling
Picture of 857 Maiden Lane
857 Maiden Lane Benton, NY
Living Area: 1498 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $365,000 Selling
Picture of 2137 Toll Road
2137 Toll Road Phelps, NY
Living Area: 1946 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $250,000 Selling
Picture of 4033 Nys Route 14 Highway
4033 Nys Route 14 Highway Starkey, NY
Living Area: 2052 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $320,000 Selling
Picture of 10787 Slayton Road
10787 Slayton Road Conquest, NY
Living Area: 1864 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $350,000 Selling
Picture of 4233 Voorhees Road
4233 Voorhees Road Potter, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $980,000 Listing
Picture of 4894 Hallock Road
4894 Hallock Road Tyrone, NY
Living Area: 2504 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $895,000 Selling
Picture of 1874 Dombroski Road
1874 Dombroski Road Barrington, NY
Living Area: 1744 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $239,000 Selling
Picture of 4805 Co Road 6
4805 Co Road 6 Geneva Town, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $707,000 Selling
Picture of 2003 Loree Road
2003 Loree Road Benton, NY
Living Area: 1738 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $405,000 Selling
Picture of 2336 Barnes Road
2336 Barnes Road Jerusalem, NY
Living Area: 1176 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $590,000 Selling
Picture of 3356 3356 Himrod Road
3356 3356 Himrod Road Milo, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $422,000 Selling
Picture of 1397 Townline Road
1397 Townline Road Torrey, NY
Living Area: 1761 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,070,000 Selling
Picture of 5106 Co Road 6
5106 Co Road 6 Geneva Town, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,105,000 Selling
Picture of 00 Arnold Road
00 Arnold Road Gorham, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $649,000 Selling
Picture of 5252 Twitchell Road
5252 Twitchell Road Gorham, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $529,000 Selling
Picture of approx. 5252 Twitchell Road
approx. 5252 Twitchell Road Gorham, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $399,000 Selling
Picture of 4076 State Route 245
4076 State Route 245 Gorham, NY
Living Area: 1300 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $325,000 Selling
Picture of 3060 Co Road 6
3060 Co Road 6 Geneva Town, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $478,000 Listing
Picture of 9133 US Route 20A
9133 US Route 20A Richmond, NY
Living Area: 1984 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $202,000 Selling
Picture of 591 Lovejoy Road
591 Lovejoy Road Benton, NY
Living Area: 2576 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $405,000 Selling
Picture of 1784 Lane Development
1784 Lane Development Potter, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $6,000 Selling
Picture of 1794 Lane Development
1794 Lane Development Potter, NY
Living Area: 840 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $145,000 Selling
Picture of 1366 County House Road
1366 County House Road Fayette, NY
Living Area: 1621 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $120,000 Selling
Picture of 3 Thompson Station Road
3 Thompson Station Road Phelps, NY
Living Area: 2058 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $190,000 Selling
Picture of 3289 State Route 21 Highway
3289 State Route 21 Highway Palmyra, NY
Living Area: 1847 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $310,000 Listing
Picture of 2852 Baldwin Road
2852 Baldwin Road Benton, NY
Living Area: 1568 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $955,000 Selling
Picture of 2935 State Route 89
2935 State Route 89 Savannah, NY
Living Area: 2244 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $375,000 Selling
Picture of 2666 Himrod Road
2666 Himrod Road Milo, NY
Living Area: 2283 Sqft.
06/04/2026 $300,000 Selling
Picture of 00 Bigelow Hill Road
00 Bigelow Hill Road Tyrone, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $155,000 Selling
Picture of 00 Himrod Road
00 Himrod Road Milo, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,389,200 Selling
Picture of 00 Rte 96a
00 Rte 96a Lodi, NY
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $130,000 Selling

Work together on Arizona.com

You can contact an agent to request a showing, ask a question, or request more information about a listing.

Contact Agent

Service Areas

Jerusalem, NY
Barrington, NY
Milo, NY
Seneca, NY
Benton, NY
Tyrone, NY
Middlesex, NY
Potter, NY
Gorham, NY
Tyre, NY
Torrey, NY
Orange, NY
Arcadia, NY
Lodi, NY
Geneva Town, NY
Hopewell, NY
Junius, NY
Starkey, NY
Phelps, NY
Conquest, NY
Richmond, NY
Fayette, NY
Palmyra, NY
Savannah, NY

Popular Search Queries

Single Family Homes for Sale in Jerusalem, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Jerusalem, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Jerusalem, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Jerusalem, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Jerusalem, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Jerusalem, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Jerusalem, NY
Luxury Homes for Sale in Jerusalem, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Jerusalem, NY
Open Houses in Jerusalem, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Gorham, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Gorham, NY
Luxury Homes for Sale in Gorham, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Gorham, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Gorham, NY
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Gorham, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Gorham, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Gorham, NY
New Construction Homes for Sale in Gorham, NY
Open Houses in Gorham, NY
Single Family Homes for Sale in Arcadia, NY
Affordable Homes for Sale in Arcadia, NY
Single Story Homes for Sale in Arcadia, NY
Business for Sale in Arcadia, NY
Commercial Real Estate for Sale in Arcadia, NY
Historic Homes for Sale in Arcadia, NY
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Arcadia, NY
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Arcadia, NY
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Arcadia, NY
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Arcadia, NY


Powered by Realty.com

Realty.com
  • Home
  • Buying
  • Selling

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility
  • Licensing