arizona.com Realty.com
  • Buying
  • Selling
  1. Home
  2. NC
  3. Lake Toxaway
  4. Balistreri Realty

Balistreri Realty

P.o. Box 210

Lake Toxaway, NC

Team Members

Kathryn Balistreri

Melisa Collins

Disclaimer: This page displays real estate agents and offices generated from active and closed MLS listings affiliated with this office. While we make every effort to provide accurate information, there may be inaccuracies due to factors such as fluctuating staff, office name changes, changes of address, and other varying circumstances. If you are the owner of the office or an agent listed here and would like to advertise, please fill out the form at https://www.realty.com/advertise.

Listings & Recent Sales (87)

Active Rental Sold

For Sale (10)

Address Bed / Bath Listing Price
Picture of 1734 Toxaway Drive
1734 Toxaway Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
5 Beds, 5 Baths
$3,295,000
Picture of 1747 Cold Mountain Road
1747 Cold Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
6 Beds, 8 Baths
$8,900,000
Picture of 30 Top of the Ridge Road
30 Top of the Ridge Road Cashiers, NC
-, 0 Baths
$484,000
Picture of 275 West Club Boulevard
275 West Club Boulevard Lake Toxaway, NC
4 Beds, 4 Baths
$1,995,000
Picture of L002R Seminole Way
L002R Seminole Way Lake Toxaway, NC
-, 0 Baths
$299,000
Picture of 302 Cambridge Drive
302 Cambridge Drive Brevard, NC
2 Beds, 2 Baths
$639,000
Picture of 545 South East Shore Drive
545 South East Shore Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
3 Beds, 4 Baths
$3,800,000
Picture of Lot 3 Cherokee Cir
Lot 3 Cherokee Cir Lake Toxaway, NC
-, 0 Baths
$24,900
Picture of MR51 Meadow Ridge Dr
MR51 Meadow Ridge Dr Lake Toxaway, NC
-, 0 Baths
$74,000
Picture of 721 Lakeside Drive
721 Lakeside Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
3 Beds, 5 Baths
$1,699,000

Sold (77)

Address Sold date Last List Price Represented
Picture of 146 Long Hunters Road
146 Long Hunters Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $670,000 Selling
Picture of 256 S Buckberry Drive
256 S Buckberry Drive Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $595,000 Listing
Picture of 336 S E Shore Drive
336 S E Shore Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $739,000 Listing
Picture of 96 Brassie Drive
96 Brassie Drive Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,795,000 Colisting
Picture of 522 Toxaway Court
522 Toxaway Court Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $595,000 Listing
Picture of 74 Echo Springs Point
74 Echo Springs Point Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $2,450,000 Selling
Picture of 541 NE Shore Drive
541 NE Shore Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $825,000 Listing
Picture of 412 Cherokee Trace
412 Cherokee Trace Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $655,000 Colisting
Picture of Lot G 21 Bailey Lane
Lot G 21 Bailey Lane Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $29,500 Colisting
Picture of 106 Bee Tree Way
106 Bee Tree Way Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $2,525,000 Listing
Picture of 91 Club Colony Lane
91 Club Colony Lane Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,295,000 Listing
Picture of 100 Fairway Villas Drive 100
100 Fairway Villas Drive 100 Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $524,900 Selling
Picture of Lot 15 B W Club
Lot 15 B W Club Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $899,000 Selling
Picture of 154 S E Shore Drive
154 S E Shore Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $495,000 Selling
Picture of Lot 3 Rainbows End Lane
Lot 3 Rainbows End Lane Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $21,900 Selling
Picture of 76 Brassie Drive
76 Brassie Drive Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,425,000 Selling
Picture of 1634 Lonesome Valley Road
1634 Lonesome Valley Road Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $5,545,000 Selling
Picture of 37 Azalea Court
37 Azalea Court Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $445,000 Selling
Picture of 44 Country Club Village Drive 3
44 Country Club Village Drive 3 Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,495,000 Selling
Picture of 26 Feldspar Lane
26 Feldspar Lane Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $179,000 Selling
Picture of 1338 Fairway Drive
1338 Fairway Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $649,000 Listing
Picture of Lot33Rev Cold Mountain Road
Lot33Rev Cold Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $795,000 Selling
Picture of 2454 Cold Mountain Road
2454 Cold Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $845,000 Selling
Picture of 174 Rhododendron Run
174 Rhododendron Run Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $749,900 Listing
Picture of 963 Cold Mountain Road
963 Cold Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $2,875,000 Selling
Picture of 233 Cardinal Trace
233 Cardinal Trace Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,950,000 Listing
Picture of Lt 20,21 Stone Cliffs Lane
Lt 20,21 Stone Cliffs Lane Cashiers, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $99,999 Listing
Picture of 224 Toxaway Court
224 Toxaway Court Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,395,000 Selling
Picture of 94 Tuttle Way
94 Tuttle Way Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,995,000 Listing
Picture of TR B Little Terrapin Road
TR B Little Terrapin Road Cashiers, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $129,500 Colisting
Picture of 535 Hawk Mountain Road
535 Hawk Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $2,795,000 Selling
Picture of 258 Club Colony Lane
258 Club Colony Lane Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $940,000 Colisting
Picture of 1289 Toxaway Drive
1289 Toxaway Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $475,000 Listing
Picture of 131 Club Colony Lane
131 Club Colony Lane Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $315,000 Listing
Picture of 1705 Cold Mountain Road
1705 Cold Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,895,000 Selling
Picture of 59 E Shore Drive
59 E Shore Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $30,000 Selling
Picture of 92 Rocky Ridge Road
92 Rocky Ridge Road Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $549,000 Listing
Picture of 1578 W Club
1578 W Club Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,150,000 Listing
Picture of 2641 Cold Mountain Road
2641 Cold Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,149,000 Listing
Picture of 1424 W Club
1424 W Club Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $2,190,000 Selling
Picture of 175 Deep Ford Falls
175 Deep Ford Falls Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $598,000 Listing
Picture of 188 Club Colony Lane
188 Club Colony Lane Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $469,000 Listing
Picture of 5352 North Norton Road
5352 North Norton Road Cullowhee, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $239,500 Selling
Picture of 633 Seminole Way
633 Seminole Way Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $369,000 Selling
Picture of 424 Cherokee Trace
424 Cherokee Trace Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $539,000 Selling
Picture of 28 Toxaway Point 6
28 Toxaway Point 6 Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $365,000 Selling
Picture of 1958 W Club
1958 W Club Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $2,675,000 Listing
Picture of 107 Ridge Colony
107 Ridge Colony Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,795,000 Selling
Picture of 315 Mills Creek Trace
315 Mills Creek Trace Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $995,000 Selling
Picture of 650 Toxaway Drive
650 Toxaway Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,495,000 Listing
Picture of 110 Eagle Ridge Road
110 Eagle Ridge Road Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $349,000 Listing
Picture of 1625 Toxaway Drive
1625 Toxaway Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $325,000 Selling
Picture of 140 Red Bird Circle
140 Red Bird Circle Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,365,000 Listing
Picture of 87 SE Shore Drive
87 SE Shore Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $312,000 Selling
Picture of 422 W Club
422 W Club Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,259,000 Selling
Picture of 1725 Buckberry N
1725 Buckberry N Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $689,000 Selling
Picture of 476 Toxaway Court
476 Toxaway Court Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $429,900 Listing
Picture of 648 Sky Lake Drive
648 Sky Lake Drive Highlands, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $395,000 Listing
Picture of 4176 W Club
4176 W Club Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $2,495,000 Selling
Picture of 122 Indian Trace
122 Indian Trace Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,499,000 Listing
Picture of 117 Moltz Court
117 Moltz Court Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,095,000 Selling
Picture of 822 W Club
822 W Club Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $2,750,000 Selling
Picture of 311 Lakeside Drive
311 Lakeside Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $465,000 Selling
Picture of 347 S E Shore Drive
347 S E Shore Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $4,200,000 Listing
Picture of 1195 Cold Mountain Road
1195 Cold Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $1,395,000 Listing
Picture of Lot 18 Feldspar Lane
Lot 18 Feldspar Lane Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $295,000 Selling
Picture of 50 Clearwater Point
50 Clearwater Point Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $2,215,000 Selling
Picture of Lot 36 Piney Ridge Court
Lot 36 Piney Ridge Court Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $69,000 Selling
Picture of 342 Hawk Mountain Road
342 Hawk Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $925,000 Selling
Picture of 4067 W Club
4067 W Club Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $409,000 Selling
Picture of 590 Cherokee Trace
590 Cherokee Trace Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $375,000 Selling
Picture of 114 Hilltop Road
114 Hilltop Road Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $799,000 Listing
Picture of 165 Mossy Rock Road
165 Mossy Rock Road Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $539,900 Listing
Picture of BB LT 87 W Club
BB LT 87 W Club Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $795,000 Listing
Picture of 1528 Cold Mountain Road
1528 Cold Mountain Road Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $3,900,000 Listing
Picture of 40 Piney Ridge Court
40 Piney Ridge Court Sapphire, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $875,000 Listing
Picture of RRL020 Lakeside Drive
RRL020 Lakeside Drive Lake Toxaway, NC
Living Area: Sqft.
06/04/2026 $56,000 Listing

Work together on Arizona.com

You can contact an agent to request a showing, ask a question, or request more information about a listing.

Contact Agent

Service Areas

Lake Toxaway, NC
Cashiers, NC
Brevard, NC
Sapphire, NC
Cullowhee, NC
Highlands, NC

Popular Search Queries

Single Family Homes for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
Luxury Homes for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
New Construction Homes for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
Business for Sale in Lake Toxaway, NC
Single Family Homes for Sale in Brevard, NC
Luxury Homes for Sale in Brevard, NC
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Brevard, NC
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Brevard, NC
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Brevard, NC
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Brevard, NC
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Brevard, NC
Historic Homes for Sale in Brevard, NC
Homes with Granite Countertops for Sale in Brevard, NC
New Construction Homes for Sale in Brevard, NC
Single Family Homes for Sale in Sapphire, NC
Luxury Homes for Sale in Sapphire, NC
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sapphire, NC
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Sapphire, NC
Business for Sale in Sapphire, NC
Commercial Real Estate for Sale in Sapphire, NC
Affordable Homes for Sale in Sapphire, NC
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sapphire, NC
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sapphire, NC
5 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Sapphire, NC
Single Family Homes for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
Luxury Homes for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
Homes with 2 Car Garages for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
Affordable Homes for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
Historic Homes for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
Homes with Pools for Sale in Cullowhee, NC
Single Family Homes for Sale in Highlands, NC
Luxury Homes for Sale in Highlands, NC
3 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Highlands, NC
2 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Highlands, NC
Homes with Large Lots for Sale in Highlands, NC
Homes with Acreage for Sale in Highlands, NC
Homes with Wood Floors for Sale in Highlands, NC
Commercial Real Estate for Sale in Highlands, NC
Affordable Homes for Sale in Highlands, NC
Historic Homes for Sale in Highlands, NC


Powered by Realty.com

Realty.com
  • Home
  • Buying
  • Selling

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility
  • Licensing